Witness Justice
Witness JusticeSupport WJMailing ListVolunteerSite MapContact Us

Survivor Resources
Health and Wellness
Advocacy
Helping a Survivor
Justice Systems
WJ Programs
Virtual Community
Partnerships and Sponsors
About WJ
News Room
For Service Providers
Links
WJ Home Page
Site Search
   

Visit Our Facebook Group


Victims' Rights
Print Version

Imbalanced Rights – a Predicament for Crime Victims

The Victim

The Defendant

Becomes an unwilling target. Is presumed to have chosen to engage in unlawful and unjust activity.
Is traumatized from the violent act. Is innocent until proven guilty.
Is supported by federal and state legislation, and the nature and degree of that support varies from state to state. Is supported by the U.S. Constitution.
Has the right to remain silent. Has the right to remain silent.
Is provided access to a local victim assistance bureau, if and when available. In most cases, a crime must be reported in order to access state services. Has the right to an attorney, free of charge.
Must wait until the state and defense are ready for trial. Has the right to a speedy trial.
Must trust the state to pursue a fair trial. Has the personal right to a fair trial.
Is not always informed of the offenders bail release (two-thirds of all victims are not notified). Has the right to seek bail release.
Is prohibited from being present while other witnesses testify. Has the right to personally question each witness.
Must rely on the state to present witnesses that will make the best case against the defendant. Has the right to present witnesses to testify on his/her behalf.
Is forced to testify and endure a trial if he/she wants to see justice served. Can decide whether to testify.
Must trust the state to determine the best course for pursuing justice — and an appropriate sentence for the crime. Has the right to a jury trial.
Has no voice in jury selection. Has a right to direct involvement in jury selection.
May or may not be informed of a plea agreement and related negotiations. Has the right to negotiate and accept a plea agreement.
Must assertively pursue the opportunity to read an impact statement at sentencing. Has the right to appeal a guilty verdict and can file multiple motions for appeal hearings.
May or may not receive support by persons in court, protective orders, restitution or victim advocates. While incarcerated, receives free room and board, medical care, a college education or technical training, psychological counseling, and access to gym facilities and legal resources.
Has no "victim protection program" to relocate or change identity to ensure safety. Can benefit from the Witness Protection Program where sentences are forgiven and relocation and identity changes are paid for by taxpayers in exchange for witness testimony.
Receives no financial support or reparation from tax dollars. Is housed, educated and otherwise tended to with tax dollars..

While we believe the comparison between victim and defendant rights is helpful in illustrating the need to enhance victim rights, we also understand that many offenders are also survivors of violence who may themselves want healing and need trauma counseling, support, or assistance with substance abuse as part of that process.

Without question, there are sociopathic perpetrators who might not respond to rehabilitation or therapy. However, many of those incarcerated are survivors of violence who have made unhealthy and destructive choices that have led them to committing violent offenses. While acknowledging this fact in no way exonerates the perpetrator or rationalizes the crime, these survivors also need help and healing.

Source: U.S. Department of Justice and other public information resources

© 2003 Witness Justice
All Rights Reserved


Witness Justice, PO Box 2516, Rockville, MD 20847-2516, 301.846.9110, 800.4WJ.HELP, info@witnessjustice.org

Last Updated on July 21, 2010

Disclaimer

Copyright © 2002 - 2010 Witness Justice